The following players made the 2009 NCFL All-Stars. 

Among the leaders was All-American candidate Lance Butler who lead the NCFL with 115 tackles and 26.5 tackles for loss in 10 regular season games.  Second place was 90 tackles.  Also an All-American candidate for this season was Maurice Johnson who had 29.5 tackles, 5 for loss, 3 sacks and 4 interceptions for 147 return yards and 2 touchdowns, and 8 tipped passes.  He also played some tailback and returned a few kicks.  Maurice was a great team leader and played several games while hurt and did not let up at all.  He also was the NCFL player of the week for week 1, which made him the first player in the league to ever get that award.

Darnell Jefferies, in his first year with the Lawmen finished 4th in the NCFL in rushing with 538 yards and played in only 9 games.  That is a very good stat, considering that the Lawmen offensive line was depleated for most of the second half of the season and the team ended up using a lot of defensive linemen to play offensive line in the last several games, including the Playoffs.  First year defensive back Dennis Taylor also did an outstanding job in 2009 with 3 interceptions, 131 return yards and 2 TDs and was a shut down cornerback all season long.  First year punter Taylor Richardson also did a great job all season long and was a well deserved all-star.